Good News: An enewsletter for donors and nonprofits
on strategic planning, governance, fundraising, and executive leadership.
Listen, Speak, Give
At a recent funders’ gathering in Boston hosted by the Social Innovation Forum, I appreciated the common theme among several panelists who offered the following advice to donors: “Listen, Speak, Give.”
A few of my own thoughts about each below.
Listen
From the President of the Center for Effective Philanthropy, to a Senior Program Officer of the Island Foundation, to the CEO of SIF, to the President of the Viney Wallach Foundation, each implored funders to listen to community members when identifying community challenges and the means by which to meet them. Too often I see funders who are not my clients presuming that they know what is best for others, despite never having been physically present in a community or speaking with those closest to the circumstances on the ground. It can be hard for otherwise accomplished individuals to act with humility and ask questions rather than presume to have the answers to complex questions.
Speak
Engaging in genuine listening sessions and conversations with a bias toward thinking that those in the community know what they need best is only part of what is meant when asking funders to speak. Also important is funders speaking out on matters or even words that seem controversial now but never were. If those with the most resources and security can’t speak truth to power, who can? A funder’s example of taking a position and modeling how to move forward can be even more important than a funder’s financial support. So plant your flag in the ground wisely and be prepared to defend it against those in opposition, especially when others can’t.
Give
Of course financial investments in organizations doing good work are critical. But what is the right balance between leveraging resources on behalf of those in crisis and meeting one’s responsibilities as a fiduciary to a foundation or other funder? Much has been said and written about boards allocating more than the minimum requirement of 5%. Not enough donors understand that 5% is a floor, not a ceiling, to their annual giving. In an investment environment that has for decades returned far north of 5% annually for most foundations, why not follow some funders’ leads and give annually at 7%? Or even 10-25% with the understanding that investment returns and other inflows are likely to replenish any temporary dips that result from meeting moments of extraordinary need?
Whether you are listening with humility, speaking with courage or giving robustly, I hope that this season of thanks inspires gratitude for those nonprofits who are on the front lines attempting to meet the world’s most pressing, extraordinarily challenging needs. Celebrate the fact that there are funders out there who are inspiring and going well beyond their required philanthropic monetary investments.
Happy Thanksgiving.
Stuff Steve is Watching, Listening to, and Reading
The Art of Fighting (60 minute watch)
“There are four common triggers of tears in the life of a group. The first is an influx of new members. The second is the group is shrinking. Third, one of my favorites, is perceived organizational hypocrisy. And the fourth, counterintuitively, is massive success verging on mission completion that can create existential conflict.” Priya Parker and Daniel Pink in conversation on the Family Action Network
The Myth That Made Us (43 minute listen)
“Take a walk into a community where people are not the same as you, you know, middle, upper middle class white guy or woman. Take a walk. Get to know some people. Talk, listen, actually. Mostly listen to folks who live in those areas and then come back and say it’s not what Jeff says, it’s not that bad. Actually get to know some people. This, I think, is how narratives will change because it is how important narratives have changed in the past.” Jeff Fuhrer in conversation with Andrew Keen on Keen On America
A Sector In Crisis (20 minute read)
“Beyond-the-grant assistance in fundraising, technology, and legal aid are the areas with the highest discrepancies between what is being provided and what nonprofit CEOs say would be most useful for their organization right now. The most common form of assistance that grantees would find useful, reported by 60% of nonprofit CEOs, is help with fundraising strategy and donor development. Currently, 41% of foundations report providing such support.” Evolving Foundation Responses to a Sector in Crisis, The Center for Effective Philanthropy